Fight! Fight! Aveda Hand Relief Vs Trilogy Ultra Hydrating Hand Cream

By Aisling | November 12 2012 | 21 Comments

Hmm here’s an interesting one.  I thought this pair would be fairly evenly stacked against one another.

I was wrong.

 

 

Aveda Hand Relief (oh we will NEVER get over our hilarious smutty thoughts about that name, sorry) is an old champion.  Along with Elizabeth Arden 8 Hour Hand Cream it’s an old friend of mine and an absolute staple beside my bed, where I actually do remember to put handcream on every night.

Having run out of either I picked up another tube in the Carton House Spa recently (where I had my embarrassing drool on the floor experience during an Indian Head massage) and was instantly satisfied with it once again.  You can’t improve upon perfection I thought.

Or can you?  I then went on to try the new Hand Cream offering from Trilogy.  I love Trilogy too, their Rosehip Oil is such a work of perfection that it’s won the serum category with such a massive margin in the Awards for the last two years that we’ll have to put it in a Hall of Fame or something if it does it again next year.

But this new hand cream is no great shakes at all I’m afraid.  Because I was using the two at the same time I was instantly aware of the difference in texture and consistency.  The Trilogy is far thinner and doesn’t have that instant softening and rejuvenating effect that the Aveda does.

And although the Aveda offering seems more expensive at around €30 a tube you’re paying for 125ml instead of €14.95 for 75ml of Trilogy.  You do the math – it’s still not worth it.

 

Now I’m not picking on Trilogy AT ALL with this next point (because it’s standard industry practice to fool you into thinking you’re getting more than you are) – but I don’t know if you can see well enough in the slightly blurry photo I put up above that the Trilogy contents er “settle” in the tube.  I’d only used the cream twice when I took this photo on holiday and the contents only reach to slightly above the blue line.

So although the tubes don’t look that out of sync with one another – you’re getting more with the Aveda.  And it’s hands down the better product (excuse the pun.)

And sure you can’t beat a bit of hand relief eh?  Smut aside you can see who clearly wins this fight.  If you’re shelling out for a luxury hand cream go for the Aveda.

Correction: I apologise to Trilogy – I made an error about the price – it’s €14.95 instead of the €21 I originally stated.  However I still don’t think it’s any good – sorry guys!

Reviews , ,
 

21 Replies to "Fight! Fight! Aveda Hand Relief Vs Trilogy Ultra Hydrating Hand Cream"

  • Lolo says:

    I thought elizabeth arden did the 8 hour hand cream, or do estee lauder have one too?

  • Shona says:

    Great article! I am obsessed with hand creams these days. What exactly happens after we hit the wrong side of 30 and all of a sudden my hands are painfully dry all the time? Its amazing the range of quality you get in hand creams, all are not created equal. Am using Clarins Jeunesse de Mains at home and keep Aveeno hand cream at work. Might need to incorporate some Aveda!

  • Shona says:

    Great article! I am obsessed with hand creams these days. What exactly happens after we hit the wrong side of 30 and all of a sudden my hands are painfully dry all the time? Its amazing the range of quality you get in hand creams, all are not created equal. Am using Clarins Jeunesse de Mains at home and keep Aveeno hand cream at work. Might need to incorporate some Aveda!

  • Edelmc says:

    Aveda hand cream is good but I think kiehls hand cream wins hands down with clarins in a close second

  • The Aveda one is going on my Christmas list!

  • fififinx says:

    It would take a lot to budge me from L’Occitane, I’m afraid

  • Shygirl says:

    Hand Relief! Ha Ha! I wouldn’t be able to go into a shop and but it, I’d have to get it online.

  • Shygirl says:

    And buy it I mean

  • Aisling *Aisling* says:

    I have to agree the L’Occitsne Shea butter and the Clarins are BRILLIANT luxury picks too!
    I love handcream and am always trying out new ones – some of the lower priced ones are fab too – have a look at the Awards, there are some great choices there. For beside the kitchen sink you can’t beat Vaseline hand cream or Neutrogena

  • Aisling *Aisling* says:

    Shygirl- EVERY time I buy it I have a secret snigger!

  • xgirl says:

    In fairness to Trilogy, I think you might have the wrong price information. I bought the handcream recently and while I can’t remember exactly what I paid, I know it wasn’t as high as €21 – maybe more around €14 or so. I do like it, but it’s not as rich as I was expecting, or maybe my hands are just a lost cause when I wash them a million times a day at the moment. I like the Aveda one too, though I don’t find it super hydrating. I still miss my old Nuxe favourite!

  • Miruku says:

    Trilogy isn’t available in Japan (afaik?) so I seem to have missed the boat on this one. I agree with the other girls that it’s hard to beat L’Occitane and Elizabeth Arden. I’d probably give Aveda a go, I had great success with their shampoo a few years ago.

    And their free tea in Brown Thomas was yum!

  • cch says:

    Anybody else have skin on their hands like mine that doesn’t get too dry most of the time and when I try any highly recommended hand creams my opinion is “meh”? I haven’t tried these two but I have tried the Clarins, Kiehls, 8 Hour ones and lots of others too. But then there’s others that 10 minutes after applying my skin feels tight and worse off than if I hadn’t used them!! I guess my hands don’t need them too much (“normal” as opposed to dry hand-skin type??), I just like the idea of using them!!
    Similarly for highly recommended body lotions!

  • Shygirl says:

    Cch, maybe you need to exfoliate your hands to get dead skin off, and let the lotions into the skin. Even if you use something like sugar and olive oil.

  • Gracie says:

    @ Shygirl : I was just thinking the same thing!! I don’t think I’d be able to keep a straight face and ask for the Hand Relief (tehehe) from the sales assistant.

  • Aisling *Aisling* says:

    Lolo you are so right! I’m ALWAYS doing that – thanks!

  • Ladyjane says:

    Wasn’t so pushed on nuxe hand cream. Loving loccataine and lush as my luxury brands. Can’t beat garnier for work though. Constant washing and alcohol gel are murder on my hands. garnier seven day range is the only one I’ve found that gives some protection as well as moisturising them. Neutrogena ones are too greasy and take too long to dry in.

  • Aisling *Aisling* says:

    xgirl – holding my hands up to that one too! I made two mistakes in this post. But I actually don’t think it’s worth that price either in all honesty
    I think I will have to resign like the head of the BBC. Anyone fancy giving me the same payout he’s getting!

  • PinkPanther says:

    Laura Mercier are my fav hand creams. So sweet I want to eat my hands, especially pistachio.

  • freckleface says:

    Dr. Hauscka do a really nice hand cream. Very moisturising!(sorry for spelling but its been a long Monday)

Leave a Reply



Content © Beaut.ie and partners

?>